Best Fish for Curry in Pakistan
Quick answer: Surmai is an excellent choice for Pakistani fish curry because its firm flesh holds together during cooking. Rohu and Catla are popular freshwater options for traditional home-style curry. Red Snapper, Dhotar and Mushka are also good choices, and Black Pomfret works well when you prefer firmer fish.
Choosing the right fish makes a big difference to your curry. Some fish have firm flesh that stays intact in gravy, while others are softer and need careful cooking. The best option depends on your taste, preferred texture, budget and how comfortable you are with fish bones.
This guide compares fish available at Ilyas Fish to help you choose the right one for traditional Pakistani fish curry.
Best Fish for Curry: Quick Comparison
| Fish | Taste | Texture | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Surmai | Savoury, rich | Firm and meaty | Traditional masala curry |
| Rohu | Mild, slightly sweet | Moderately firm, many fine bones | Freshwater fish curry |
| Catla (Thaila) | Mild | Meaty, fine bones | Homemade curry |
| Red Snapper Heera | Savoury | Firm | Spicy tomato curry |
| Dhotar | Mild | Firm | Traditional fish gravy |
| Mushka | Mild | Takes masala well | Everyday fish curry |
| Black Pomfret | Fuller flavour | Firm | Rich fish curry |
| White Pomfret | Mild, delicate | Soft | Light fish curry |
These are general cooking recommendations. Fish size, cutting style and cooking time all affect the final result.
1. Surmai – Best Overall Choice for Fish Curry
Surmai is one of the most popular sea fish in Pakistan. Its firm, meaty flesh holds its shape in gravy better than delicate fish, and its steaks absorb onion, tomato and ginger-garlic masala well.
- Firm flesh that holds together during cooking
- Ideal for thick curry pieces and steaks
- Good for spicy and tomato-based gravy
Best preparation: steaks or curry-cut pieces. Shop: Surmai Kingfish

2. Rohu – Traditional Freshwater Fish Curry
Rohu (راہو مچھلی) is a familiar freshwater fish in Pakistani homes. It has mild, slightly sweet flesh and is commonly cooked with onion, tomato, garlic, ginger and traditional spices. It has many fine bones, so take care when serving, especially to children.
Best preparation: medium curry-cut pieces. Shop: Rohu Fish
3. Catla (Thaila) – Popular Freshwater Curry Fish
Catla, known locally as Thaila (تھیلا مچھلی), is another freshwater carp used in traditional South Asian cooking. Its substantial pieces suit homemade curry, but it has fine bones. Cook the gravy first and add the fish carefully so the pieces don’t break.
Best preparation: curry-cut pieces. Shop: Catla Fish (Thaila)
4. Red Snapper Heera – For Rich Masala Curry
Red Snapper Heera has firm meat that keeps its structure in a spicy tomato gravy, and it is equally good for frying and grilling.
Best preparation: curry-cut pieces or steaks. Shop: Red Snapper Heera
5. Dhotar – Good for Traditional Fish Gravy
Dhotar (Javelin Grunter) is a marine fish with firm texture and mild flavour that takes traditional seasoning well.
Best preparation: curry-cut pieces. Shop: Dhotar Fish
6. Mushka – Practical Choice for Masala Curry
Mushka is a familiar name in Karachi’s fish markets, generally associated with the croaker group. Its mild meat takes masala well and suits curry, frying and tawa cooking.
Best preparation: curry-cut pieces. Shop: Mushka Original 3-Teeth
7. Black Pomfret – For Firmer Fish Pieces
Black Pomfret (Kala Paplet) has firmer flesh and a fuller flavour than White Pomfret, making it a good choice for masala curry, tawa cooking and grilling.
Best preparation: curry-cut portions. Shop: Black Pomfret
8. White Pomfret – For Mild, Light Curry
White Pomfret (Safaid Paplet) has mild, delicate flesh. It is best known for frying, but also makes a light curry. Prepare the gravy first, add the fish towards the end and avoid stirring.
Best preparation: larger fish cut into portions. Shop: White Pomfret
Which Fish Should You Choose?
- Firm fish pieces: Surmai or Red Snapper Heera
- Traditional freshwater curry: Rohu or Catla
- Mild seafood flavour: Mushka or Dhotar
- Fuller Paplet flavour: Black Pomfret
- Light curry: White Pomfret
If you are unsure, Surmai is a practical starting point.
Tips for Cooking Fish Curry Without Breaking the Fish
- Clean the fish and choose a suitable curry-cut size.
- Cook the onion, tomato, ginger, garlic and spice gravy first.
- Let the masala cook properly before adding the fish.
- Place the fish pieces gently into the gravy.
- Cook on medium-low heat until the fish is cooked through.
- Avoid stirring; gently swirl the pan instead.
- Serve carefully to keep the pieces intact.
Curry Cut vs Steaks vs Fillets
- Curry cut: smaller bone-in portions that fit easily into traditional gravy.
- Steaks: thick cross-section slices, best for firm fish such as Surmai.
- Fillets: fewer bones, though small bones may remain.
Not sure which cut to choose? Read our fish cleaning and cutting guide.
Where to Buy Fish for Curry in Karachi
Ilyas Fish buys fresh fish daily from Karachi’s fish markets and Karachi Fish Harbour, with free cleaning and cutting in your preferred style and delivery across Karachi and other cities in Pakistan. Browse the Ilyas Fish store, or read our guide to the best fish for frying in Pakistan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which fish is best for curry in Pakistan?
Surmai is an excellent choice for firm pieces. Rohu and Catla are popular for traditional freshwater curry.
Is Surmai good for Pakistani fish curry?
Yes. Its firm flesh holds its shape during cooking and works well with Pakistani masala.
Is Rohu good for fish curry?
Yes. Rohu is a popular freshwater curry fish, although it has many fine bones.
Can I use Catla for fish curry?
Yes. Catla works well in onion, tomato and spice-based gravy.
Is Pomfret suitable for curry?
Yes. White Pomfret is more delicate, while Black Pomfret has firmer flesh.
Surmai or Rohu — which is better for curry?
Choose Surmai for firm, steak-style pieces and Rohu for a traditional freshwater curry.
How do I stop fish from breaking in curry?
Cook the gravy first, add the fish gently and avoid frequent stirring. Add delicate fish towards the end.
Which fish has fewer bones for curry?
It depends on the species and cut. Fillets generally have fewer bones than whole fish or bone-in steaks, but small bones can remain.
Conclusion
The best fish for curry depends on your preferred flavour, texture and cooking style. Surmai, Rohu and Catla are excellent starting choices, while Dhotar, Mushka, Red Snapper and Pomfret add variety. Choose the right fish and cut, cook the masala first, and add the fish gently for a perfect Pakistani fish curry at home.


2 thoughts on “Best Fish for Curry in Pakistan”